The First Deal Is the Hardest: What Athletes Miss About Private Equity

I recently had a potential opportunity to raise capital into a European football club competing at a high level in its country.

At first glance, it was compelling.

A limited allocation left in the raise. Playoff position. Promotion upside. A short window to participate.

If you’ve played professionally, that combination hits immediately. You understand the revenue jump that comes with promotion. You understand the brand lift. You understand how quickly valuation narratives can shift.

But as we dug into the structure, the conversation became less about the club and more about the capital stack.

And that’s where the real education begins.

Narrative vs. Structure

Athletes are trained to evaluate performance directly. You watch the match. You assess the roster. You project the upside.

Private equity doesn’t work that way.

An attractive asset can still produce an underwhelming return if the structure is layered improperly. In this case, what initially looked like a straightforward entry point turned out to involve multiple entities between investor capital and the underlying club.

Top-level ownership. An SPV raising a large fund. Another vehicle raising a tranche within that. Potentially another layer where I would aggregate capital.

Every additional layer introduces potential friction:

• Management fees

• Carried interest

• Waterfall complexity

• Governance dilution

Those aren’t minor details. They determine net outcomes.

The Athlete Blind Spot

This is the part no one really explains to former players.

We understand sport. We understand locker rooms. We understand the economics of leagues. But capital architecture is a different discipline entirely.

In sport, performance is transparent. In private equity, performance is filtered through structure.

A club can achieve promotion and still produce mediocre investor returns if:

• Fees are stacked across multiple entities.

• Carry is layered without alignment.

• Investors sit too far down the waterfall.

The emotional story of the asset doesn’t override the math of the structure.

That realization is part of the transition.

The Questions That Matter

The conversation quickly shifted from “Is this club a good bet?” to much more fundamental questions:

Where does the dollar actually sit?

Who earns carry, and at what level?

Are there economics available for capital introduced?

What does the subscription agreement outline?

What does the operating agreement say about distributions and control?

These aren’t glamorous questions.

But they’re the difference between participating in a deal and understanding a deal.

Exposure Isn’t Experience

Being introduced to opportunities feels like progress. It feels like forward motion. It feels like entry into a new world.

But experience isn’t measured by access.

Experience is built by:

• Reading documents carefully.

• Modeling returns net of fees.

• Mapping out waterfalls.

• Asking uncomfortable structural questions.

Athletes are wired to act decisively. To jump in. To trust instincts.

In capital markets, instinct has to be paired with analysis.

The Real Transition

The deeper lesson isn’t about one specific opportunity.

It’s about identity.

On the field, your value was performance. In investing, your value is judgment.

Judgment requires patience. It requires slowing down when timelines feel urgent. It requires protecting the people who might trust you with their capital.

That’s a new muscle.

But it’s trainable.

The first deal isn’t about maximizing return. It’s about learning how structure works, how economics flow, and how alignment is built.

Because in this next chapter, credibility compounds just like capital does.

And the athlete who learns to read the stack — not just the scoreboard — builds something sustainable long after the final whistle.

---

If these ideas resonate, you should subscribe to the blog. I use this space to explore the realities of athlete transitions, investing, leadership, and decision-making beyond the surface-level narratives—drawing from real conversations, lived experience, and work inside sport and business. Subscribing ensures you receive future posts directly and stay connected as these themes continue to evolve.